Fitbit vs Garmin
Fitbit is the affordable everyday choice for health and sleep tracking, from the screenless $100 Fitbit Air to the $160 Charge 6. Garmin is the sports and outdoor choice: WIRED calls the Fenix 8 the best sports watch any of its reviewers has worn, and Garmin Connect is free.
Disclosure: PickedTech is reader-supported. Some links on this page are affiliate links, and we may earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. This never affects which products we recommend or how we rank them. How we make money.
How this page was made: this is a research-based guide built from manufacturer spec pages, official prices and published lab measurements from the outlets we name and link. We haven’t tested these products ourselves, and we don’t invent scores. Our methodology.
Quick answer
Choose Fitbit Air (from $99.99) if you want simple health and sleep tracking under $200 or you want a screenless band (Fitbit Air). Choose Garmin Vivoactive 6 (from $150) if you run, cycle or train seriously, you want long battery life and onboard maps or you don’t want to pay a subscription for core features.
Last updated Prices checked Oct 2026
Check Fitbit Air price (opens in a new tab)Check Garmin Vivoactive 6 price (opens in a new tab)
Key facts at a glance
| Fitbit Air | Garmin Vivoactive 6 | |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest tracker | Fitbit Air, $99.99 | Vivosmart 5, $150 |
| WIRED top pick | Fitbit Air ($100) | Vivoactive 6 ($300) |
| Premium flagship | Sense 2, $250 | Fenix 8 AMOLED, $1,000+ |
| Battery life | Up to 6–10 days | About a week (Vivosmart 5) to weeks (Fenix 8) |
| Subscription | Google Health Premium for Gemini coaching | Connect free; Connect+ $70/yr optional |
Pick Fitbit for comfortable, affordable all-day health and sleep tracking. WIRED[1][2] recommends the screenless $100 Fitbit Air to most people and the $160 Charge 6 if you want a display. Coaching built with Gemini requires a Google Health Premium membership. Pick Garmin for running, training and outdoor sports, longer-lasting watches, and free Connect software. WIRED’s top Garmin for most people is the $300 Vivoactive 6.
Fitbit Air vs Garmin Vivoactive 6: side-by-side
| Fitbit | Garmin | |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest tracker | Fitbit Air, $99.99 | Vivosmart 5, $150 |
| WIRED top pick | Fitbit Air ($100) | Vivoactive 6 ($300) |
| Premium flagship | Sense 2, $250 | Fenix 8 AMOLED, $1,000+ |
| Battery life | Up to 6–10 days | About a week (Vivosmart 5) to weeks (Fenix 8) |
| Subscription | Google Health Premium for Gemini coaching | Connect free; Connect+ $70/yr optional |
| Best for | Everyday health and sleep | Running, training, outdoor sports |
| Phone compatibility | iOS and Android | iOS and Android |
How much do they cost?
Fitbit Air plans
| Option | Price | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Fitbit Air | $99.99 | Screenless band; up to 7 days battery |
| Fitbit Inspire 3 | $100 | Up to 10 days battery; no built-in GPS |
| Fitbit Charge 6 | $159.95 | Built-in GPS, ECG app; up to 7 days |
| Fitbit Versa 4 | $200 | Smartwatch; up to 6 days |
| Fitbit Sense 2 | $250 | ECG, skin temperature; up to 6 days |
Garmin Vivoactive 6 plans
| Option | Price | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Vivosmart 5 | $150 | Basic band; week-long battery |
| Forerunner 165 | $200 | Entry-level running watch |
| Vivoactive 6 | $300 | WIRED’s best overall Garmin |
| Forerunner 970 | $750 | Premium running watch |
| Fenix 8 AMOLED | $1,000+ | Best outdoor and sports watch (WIRED) |
What are the pros and cons?
Fitbit Air: pros
- Cheaper: $100 Air and Inspire 3
- Detailed, actionable sleep data (WIRED)
- Fitbit Air weighs just 12 grams
- WIRED’s Garmin reviewer rates Fitbit’s Health Coach the best she’s used
Fitbit Air: cons
- GPS less accurate than dedicated sports watches (WIRED)
- Gemini coaching requires Google Health Premium
- Smartwatch future uncertain alongside Pixel Watch (WIRED)
Garmin Vivoactive 6: pros
- Garmin Connect has always been free (WIRED)
- Best sports watch WIRED reviewers have worn (Fenix 8)
- Advanced running metrics on the Forerunner line
- Battery that can last weeks on Fenix models
Garmin Vivoactive 6: cons
- More expensive across the range
- Lifestyle Vivoactive 6 is geared toward golf and racquet sports
- Some features need Connect+ or extra accessories
Which should you choose: Fitbit Air or Garmin Vivoactive 6?
For most people who want to track health, sleep and daily activity, Fitbit is the better value. WIRED[1][2] calls the $100 Fitbit Air the one it would recommend to most people and the Charge 6 the best fitness tracker for beginners. If you run, train for events or spend time outdoors, Garmin is worth the higher price. WIRED says even expensive Garmins age very well, Connect software has always been free, and the Fenix 8 is the best sports watch any of its reviewers has worn.
Choose Fitbit Air if…
- You want simple health and sleep tracking under $200
- You want a screenless band (Fitbit Air)
- You want AI health coaching and don’t mind a membership
Choose Garmin Vivoactive 6 if…
- You run, cycle or train seriously
- You want long battery life and onboard maps
- You don’t want to pay a subscription for core features
Pricing compared
Google sells the Fitbit Air from $99.99 and the Charge 6 at $159.95. WIRED[1][2] lists the Inspire 3 at $100, the Versa 4 at $200 and the Sense 2 at $250. Garmin starts higher: WIRED lists the Vivosmart 5 at $150, the Forerunner 165 at $200, the Vivoactive 6 at $300 and the Forerunner 970 at $750, with the Fenix 8 AMOLED from about $1,000.
Subscriptions
Google says the Fitbit Air’s personalized coaching built with Gemini is included with a Google Health Premium membership. The Air and Charge 6 store pages offer 3 months of Google Health Premium. WIRED[1][2] says one of Garmin’s biggest pluses is that its Connect software has always been free. Connect+, Garmin’s optional AI-enabled subscription, costs $70 a year.
Sports and outdoor tracking
WIRED[1][2] says the Charge 6’s built-in GPS doesn’t rival dedicated sports watches for accuracy but is useful enough for outdoor activities. Garmin’s Forerunner line is aimed at runners: the 970 adds training features like Acute Impact Load and Running Tolerance, and WIRED’s reviewer found its heart rate matched a chest strap. The Fenix 8 can last for weeks on a charge and works as a dive computer.
Frequently asked questions
Is Fitbit or Garmin better for running?
Does Garmin require a subscription?
Sources
Pricing and plan details were checked on the official pages below as of Oct 2026. Vendors change prices, credits and plan names often, and some show regional pricing at checkout, so confirm on the vendor’s site before you buy.
- WIRED: The best Fitbit models (2026) (wired.com)
- WIRED: The best Garmin watches (2026) (wired.com)
- Google Store: Google Fitbit Air (checked October 2026) (store.google.com)
- Google Store: Fitbit Charge 6 (checked October 2026) (store.google.com)
Related
Best Fitbit to Buy in 2026
WIRED’s top Fitbit is the $99.99 Fitbit Air, a 12-gram screenless band. The Charge 6 is the best Fitbit with a screen for beginners, and the Inspire 3 is the cheapest.
best ofBest Garmin Watches of 2026
The Vivoactive 6 is the best Garmin for most people at $300. Runners should get the Forerunner 970, and the Fenix 8 is the best outdoor watch if you can afford it.
comparisonGarmin vs Apple Watch
Garmin watches last days to weeks and work with iPhone and Android. The Apple Watch has better smart features and calls but needs an iPhone and lasts about a day (Series 12) or two (Ultra 4).
comparisonGarmin Forerunner 970 vs Fenix 8
The Forerunner 970 is Garmin’s premium runner watch at $749.99. The Fenix 8 starts at $999.99 and adds rugged multisport DNA.